Chapel
The liturgics professor explained today that The Daily Offices (morning and evening prayer) and the Eucharist Services are done the same way all the time for a reason. They are done very closely, if not exactly, like the Prayer Book specifies that they be done. The rational is that if we are familiar with the basic, contemplative, and traditional way that this stuff is done, then we will know this well. By knowing this well, we should be able to adapt to the various ways that parishes do this, since (theoretically) all Episcopal worship is based on and around the way the Prayer Book lays it out.
As soon as he finished talking about it I just started to cry. (For those of you that know me well I should clarify that it was not a sobbing cry. It was just a very quiet, tears streaming down my face sort of cry.)
As I sat there, I just felt like we were putting our hands around the neck of the Episcopal Church and strangling the life out of her.
Having grown up Catholic, I appreciate the ritual of liturgy - and I appreciate it in many forms. This may suprise many of you, but I do like traditional, contemplative worship when it is done well. It can be very moving and very spiritual. I can find great comfort in the ritual of the tradition and find it very formative. That’s because I grew up with it. As a child, worship was ritualistic and liturgical.
But what about the people that didn’t grow up in a church? What about the people that aren’t familiar with the Episcopal liturgy? Or aren’t familiar with liturgy at all? What about the people that don’t know how to read the boards or navigate through the 9 books? How do we make them want to come back? Are they really going to feel the Holy Spirit moving as they fumble around in the books and try to figure out which side of the room is supposed to be reading which verse of the Psalm?
And what about the Seminarians? How are we supposed to learn different ways of doing liturgy if they never practice them? How are we to learn that doing liturgy this way might not be the best way to attract the next generation of (mostly) unchurched people to the Episcopal church?
I am trying desperately to keep an open mind. I’m working to trust that God has a reason for bringing me here. I know that I need to be open to being formed and transformed by this experience. But, in the meantime, I’m grieving having a groovy place to worship where I can dance and sing and rejoice. And, the prophet in me is terrified - terrified of going against the grain, terrified of creating tension and angst, terrified of being an outcast.
“I believe, help my unbelief.” Mark 9:24