As a general rule, I don’t respond to anonymous posts. I often respond directly to posters that begin a dialogue with me when they have attached their name, as I look for people to challenge me and my assumptions. I want the opportunity to talk with them and learn from them. The recent post by anonymous (see Red Shoes) has given me much to think about and I am appreciative for that. Unfortunately, anonymous has taken away my ability to interact directly with him/her by not taking public ownership of his/her comments. So, I’ll respond here for lack of any other option.
I think there is a misunderstanding about my frustrations with chapel. I really don’t care all that much about the rules or the shoes - and it certainly isn’t the requirement of adherence to the rules that I feel is ungracious. What frustrates me is the culture of fear and trepidation that exists in the chapel today. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard an acolyte talk about how fearful they were that they weren’t going to do things right. And they fear for good reason. I’ve seen a sacristan snap their fingers and point at an acolyte with a scowl like they were a dog or a small child. When I came to chapel early one evening to ask for a quick refresher about the order of events when setting the table, the sacristan I approached said (as rudely as possible), “Well, I’m not going to show it to you until the other acolyte gets here because I don’t want to have to do this more than once.” It’s not the rules or following the rules that frustrates me, it is the lack of grace that happens between the people in the chapel that I object to. Why can’t their be laughter about the silly things that go wrong in the chapel? Why can’t the acolytes be given really positive feedback about how well they did and made to feel good about what they are learning - even when, and maybe especially when, they’ve made some mistakes? Does this learning process have to happen in such a way that people leave feeling bad about it? Why can’t we lovingly, with a smile on our face because we are all in this together, say to someone (actually say it in person, not write it in email), “Hey, you know you’re not supposed to wear red shoes (or bright colored shirts or whatever) - what were you thinking? Please don’t do it again.” How come it can’t be fun and uplifting and be something that causes us to grow in relationship with one another, instead of being something that causes hurt feelings and divisions?
I certainly hope that no parishioner ever fears being part of the liturgical service in a parish. And, yes, I know this isn’t a parish. But, this is where we train parish priests. If the culture here is such that it is acceptable to be rude to our acolytes and to leave them feeling poorly about their imperfections (or even their deliberate acts of defiance), doesn’t that shape our impressions about how to behave as priests? Is this really how we want our parish priests interacting with their parishioners?
If you read my blog regularly, you know that I acknowledge that I have much to learn and that I am aware that I am certainly not perfect (see What I’ve Learned and The Perfect Wife). I’ve never claimed that I don’t have a “log in my own eye.” Just because we have a lot to learn doesn’t mean that we can’t be critical of the environment in which we are learning it. (Heaven knows people complain about teachers and administrative errors and the food situation all the time.) I have nothing against any of the sacristans. The ones that I know personally are wonderful people, many of whom are my friends. I am grateful that they are sacristans so that I don’t have to be. I am frustrated by a culture of fear and anxiety (that is acknowledged by many others than just me) and I will continue to talk about its effects on my experience here.