This week I am at Villanova University outside of Philadelphia at the Preaching Excellence Program. Episcopal seminary students from around the country have gathered to practice preaching and to learn more about it. Priests and homiletics professors have come to help us do just that.
The conference has us organized into groups of 8 or so, with two "faculty" members each. We each preached a full sermon to the group and then received feedback from our colleagues and our faculty about the structure, content, delivery, etc. We also preached draft versions of another sermon to get help while the sermon was a work-in-progress. Also, while here, we have attended several plenary sessions that have covered various methods and techniques for sermon writing and delivery. I have learned so much and I am so so grateful to be here.
And now, a shameless plug for the Episcopal Preaching Foundation: This foundation organizes and sponsors this event every year and brings the seminarians here at NO COST TO THE STUDENT. That's right, folks, the Preaching Foundation pays for everything, including travel. It is such an incredible thing that they do. Please please support them. Take up a special collection some Sunday. Or just make a small contribution. Whatever you do, you will be supporting the important ministry of developing preaching excellence in the Episcopal Church.
I thought I'd share the sermon that I preached to my group on Tuesday. We were each asked to preach a sermon about reconciliation and healing. I chose the text that I used, Luke 5:17-25, and this is what I wrote:
So, have you seen those commercials for Staples, the office supply store? The ones with the Easy button? There is usually some office crisis or problem that someone, who is seemingly helpless, tries to fix with some ridiculous solution. My favorite is the one with the cat. The boss walks into the employee’s office and he has an easel sitting on his desk and a cat painting is painting with her paw. She says, what is that? He says, “It’s a copy cat. He’s going to save us a boatload on color copies.” And then you realize that there is a pie chart next to the cat that the cat is trying to replicate. The boss says, “You need an Easy button.” And, of course, the announcer launches into the Staples spiel about how Staples can make color copies easier and cheaper, etc.
An Easy button. In the Staples commercial world, they portray us as helpless creatures whose office supply problems are solved by pushing an Easy Button.
----------------------------
A few years ago, a friend of mine found herself in a little crisis of her own, not with office supplies, but with her brother. When my friend was visiting her brother’s family, he made a comment about a parenting choice that she’d made, she overreacted and the next thing you know they had a horrible fight and she had said terrible things to her brother.
A couple of days later, my friend sent a letter to her brother. She apologized and explained the dynamic that had caused her bad reaction and asked for his forgiveness. She also expressed her forgiveness for what he had done. You know, pressing the Easy button - expecting that all would be forgiven and everything would go back to normal.
But, that’s not what happened. Her brother’s reply announced that he no longer wanted to spend time with her and her children. He blamed her and her “abusive behavior” for the entire incident and refused to acknowledge that he had any part in the disagreement. So much for the easy button.
As you can imagine, my friend was angry and disappointed and sad and lots of other things.
Well, because they live in separate towns it was easy to avoid each other, until it was time for their parents’ wedding anniversary. My friend said to me that she just didn’t know what to do about it. She didn’t know how her brother would behave – would he make a scene if they were in the same place? She was still angry and didn’t really trust herself to behave appropriately. And then she said something very interesting, she said, “You know, I really want to forgive him, but I just don’t feel like it anymore. I mean, I say in my head that I’ve forgiven him, but I don’t really feel any different about him, I’m still mad at him.”
-----------------------------
In today’s gospel, Jesus encounters a paralyzed man. A broken man. Really. Literally. A broken man. This man is physically broken and unable to move on his own or care for himself.
Now, I think it is safe to guess that this man was probably also spiritually broken. The text doesn’t tell us how he became paralyzed, if he was born that way or if he was injured, but I suspect that no matter how it happened, this man believes that he deserves what’s happened to him. We know from the story of the blind man and other stories that it was common for Jews in the first century to believe that physical injury or deformity were punishment for sins that someone, either the person or their parents, had committed.
This man lived not only with the physical difficulties of being paralyzed, but with the shame and the guilt that came with it. He was a broken man. Lying on a bed. Being carried by others. Broken. Guilty. Helpless.
But, he comes to Jesus. He comes with the faith that if he shows up, Jesus will heal him.
And Jesus does heal him, saying “Your sins are forgiven”. Your sins are forgiven. Jesus knows that physical healing is no good to the man if he remains spiritually broken. The man must first be reconciled to God, himself, and the world - he must lose his feelings of guilt and shame before physical healing will be worth anything. So, he says, “Your sins are forgiven.” “Your sins are forgiven.”
Naturally, as is usually the case with Jesus, the people around Jesus get nervous when he says things like this, so. Jesus replies to them by saying: “Which is easier, to say, “Your sins are forgiven you”, or to say, “Stand up and walk?”
Is it easier to say “Your sins are forgiven you” or is it easier to say “Stand up and walk?” In this passage, it almost seems like Jesus is pressing the Easy button. It does seem easy for Jesus to say these words to the man.
And it might be easy for Jesus, but I think it might not be so easy for the man. I mean, if you were paralyzed and someone told you that you were forgiven and to stand up and walk, would you even try? Or would you think they were crazy?
But the man does it. He comes to Jesus with faith - broken, shameful, guilty and helpless – but with faith. He comes to Jesus wanting healing and Jesus gives him forgiveness. And in that encounter, in relationship with the living Jesus the man accepts it – the man takes the forgiveness offered to him and is released from the shame and guilt. He sees himself as a loved child of God and is restored to wholeness. He stands up and walks.
-----------------------------------
I think my friend was a lot like that man on the pallet. Broken – she was bitter and angry. Guilty – knowing that she had caused this situation. Helpless – she knew she couldn’t make her brother forgive her and she didn’t feel like she could make herself forgive him.
And this is when it occurred to me, Christine really didn’t need her brother’s forgiveness. She needed Jesus’ forgiveness. And, Christine didn’t really need to forgive her brother she just needed to reconcile with him.
So I said to her, “You know, maybe it doesn’t really matter what you feel. I mean, I don’t feel like going to the gym and it’s not easy to get there, but I go twice a week because the exercise is good for me. I occasionally don’t feel like writing my tithing check and sometimes it’s not easy to write it, but I do because I know that it changes me – it changes my perspective about the world, it changes my relationship with God, it changes my relationship with money. Maybe what matters is that you just be faithful. That you just go forward with faith.”
I suggested to my friend that she go to her parent’s party and that she be polite and kind to her brother whenever she found herself in his proximity. She didn’t have to gush all over him or apologize again or force him to reconcile with her. She didn’t have to feel like she had forgiven him. It wasn’t going to be easy. But maybe she just needed to treat him with dignity, respect, and kindness, no matter how she actually felt about him.
And you know, it worked. Not quite like the Staples Easy button works in the commercial, but it worked. Somewhere in the process of treating her brother with dignity and respect she began to believe that he deserved that dignity and respect. She began to be relieved of her shame and guilt for her bad behavior – and accept the forgiveness that Jesus was offering, even if her brother wasn’t willing to offer it just yet. In the process of reconciliation – in the activity of reconciling – she encountered the living Jesus, she experienced the presence of the Holy Spirit and could feel herself being restored and healed. She was able to stand up and walk.
---------------------------
You know, the truth about that Staples Easy Button is that it really isn’t all that easy. Staples might have all the products that you need to run an office efficiently, but you still need to get in your car, and drive to the store, and find a place to park, and go inside, and ask for help because you can never find anything in those giant stores, and wait in line, and, oh yeah, have the money to pay for the stuff. The Staples Easy Button does not solve your office problems on the spot. It just doesn’t work that way.
I believe that reconciliation and healing work a bit like that. There is no easy button. We can’t just make reconciliation and healing happen – even if we ask for or offer forgiveness. But, we can show up. We can stay in conversation with each other. We can begin the process of reconciliation – the activity of reconciliation – even when it is hard, even when we don’t feel like it.
And somewhere in that activity, I believe we will encounter the living Jesus who forgives us and restores us to wholeness and health.